Casting a Spell: I Learn a Lesson in Pumpkin Beer Extravagance


Because very Arthur needs his Merlin … every Pumking apparently needs his Warlock.

In the great pantheon of pairings, beyond peanut butter and jelly, past bacon and anything and somewhere in the dark corner of a masochistic beer nerd’s wet dream, is Pumking and its prodigal friend, Warlock.

These two are a pairing out of force, not necessity, trying to enter the rarefied air of worship at the alter of all things foodie. Maybe it’s simply because Pumking, Southern Tier’s epic fall seasonal beer, was lonely. Even if Pumking’s annual (and fleeting) time in 2013 makes him sad, why is Warlock not necessary?

Because it’s petty much the same damned beer, that’s why.

I spotted Warlock after its under-the-radar appearance at my local bottle shop. Like any other pumpkin beer enthusiast, I didn’t think twice about picking up another pumpkin beer from Southern Tier, the now-apparent Camelot of fall seasonal beers. Don’t get me wrong, Warlock is good, but only if you like Pumking, which is polarizing enough as it is.

There is nothing different about the smell – both carry an intense pumpkin pie aroma: ginger, cloves, a little cinnamon and pie crust. These are the only beers that nail that crust smell.

The taste only differs in Warlock’s bitterness/astringency, thanks to its use of dark malts ideal for a stout. A nuttiness was unbearable at first, but mellowed enough to showcase some chocolate with your liquid pie.

And that’s it. If you’ve had Pumking, do you need to have Warlock? Probably not. Will you want to have Warlock? Probably.

Thanks to the close genetic makeup of Warlock and Pumking, I feel compelled to give it a full slate of pie slices:

pumpkin pie-pumpkin beer-beer-fall-autumn-pumpkin-full

Flying Dog’s The Fear

I want this beer to be called “TEH FEAR” so badly. The caps are important because that’s how you know to be afraid.

Flying_Dog_the_fear_pumpkin_beerBut aside from Flying Dog’s typical monstrous dog-type logo, you really don’t have to be.

TEH FEAR has a pretty great sweet malt smell with a boozy brown sugar mix. Kind of like oatmeal, except it’ll get you drunk. The taste is kind of a spice bomb, with nutmeg and cloves lighting the fuse. At 45 IBUs, it may taste a little more bitter than most pumpkin beers.

A fine imperial pumpkin beer, but Weyerbacher’s imperial version is preferred. Three pie slices for a solid effort.pumpkin pie-pumpkin beer-beer-fall-autumn-pumpkin-three

+Bryan Roth
“Don’t drink to get drunk. Drink to enjoy life.” — Jack Kerouac


15 thoughts on “Casting a Spell: I Learn a Lesson in Pumpkin Beer Extravagance

  1. I am drunk already just by looking at it

    1. Looks like we’re having a party today on the blog!


      1. Lol…Cheers!

  2. I’m interested in Warlock if for no other reason than I don’t think I’ve ever had a pumpkin stout. My gf tried a pumpkin lambic the other night…..that was some good stuff.

    1. Timmerman? I had a bottle of that last year and enjoyed it.

      If you’re able to find it – it may be too late now – the Epic/DC Brau Fermentation Without Representation is fantastic. It’s an imperial pumpkin porter.

    2. HaHaHahaha….what about Billy Chillies?

      1. I thought that one was alright. A pretty good middle-of-the-road pepper beer:

        You want trouble? Ghost Face Killah is the way to go:

      2. HAHAhahaha….you killing me Bryan, but i think i will give a try sometime.

  3. Great blog post… love it and thanks for the info… Travis @

    1. Thanks for the kind note, Travis. Glad to offer up the insight … the research was …. “tough.”

  4. After attending the Great Pumpkin Beer Festival, the consensus amongst my friends is that Pumpking was the least enjoyable and most “recommended to avoid” beers at the festival. I use my beer magic to cast doubts are your rating scale!

    1. With the huge selection of beers at the fest, I honestly wouldn’t argue that at all. I think I stand by Pumking since it’s readily available anywhere (for as long as it lasts, at least).

      My brother didn’t go to the festival, but he sent me the lineup. I had to change my pants.

      1. It was super rad. I’d have to go with Elysian Night Owl as my everyday pumpkin beer by which I’d judge others.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close